Take a free practice interview

  • Practice answering questions and get real feedback to improve
  • Get job-specific questions at the company you want
  • 95% say this improved their performance

Criminal Investigator Interview Questions

Learn how to answer the most common Criminal Investigator interview questions and land your dream job.

Top interview questions to expect

1. Tell me about a time you had to investigate a complex case.
2. How do you handle working under pressure and dealing with difficult individuals?
3. Describe a situation where you had to gather and analyze evidence.
4. How do you stay organized and prioritize your workload?
5. Tell me about a time you had to make a difficult decision.
6. How do you maintain your composure and professionalism in stressful situations?
7. What are your strengths and weaknesses as a Criminal Investigator?

Check the latest questions for this role:

Answering interview questions with STAR structure

To effectively answer behavioral interview questions, use the STAR method. STAR stands for Situation, Task, Action, and Result. This framework helps you structure your answers by providing a clear and concise explanation of a relevant experience.
* Situation: Briefly describe the situation or context of the experience.
* Task: Explain the task you were assigned or the problem you needed to solve.
* Action: Describe the specific actions you took to address the situation or task.
* Result: Highlight the positive outcome or result of your actions.

Sample answers to above interview questions


1. Tell me about a time you had to investigate a complex case.
Example Answer:
“During my time as a police officer, I was assigned to a case involving a series of burglaries in a residential neighborhood. The investigation was complex because there were multiple suspects and limited evidence. I started by meticulously reviewing all available evidence, including witness statements, security footage, and physical evidence. I then created a timeline of events and identified potential patterns. I also conducted interviews with potential suspects and witnesses, using active listening and open-ended questions to gather information. Through careful analysis and persistence, I was able to identify the perpetrator and bring them to justice.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer effectively uses the STAR method. It describes the complex situation, the task of investigating the burglaries, the specific actions taken, and the positive result of identifying the perpetrator and bringing them to justice.

2. How do you handle working under pressure and dealing with difficult individuals?
Example Answer:
“Working as a Criminal Investigator often involves high-pressure situations and dealing with individuals who may be uncooperative or hostile. I’ve learned to remain calm and focused under pressure, prioritizing tasks and maintaining a professional demeanor. In a recent investigation, I encountered a witness who was reluctant to provide information. I approached the situation with empathy and understanding, assuring the witness that their safety was my priority. By building rapport and demonstrating respect, I was able to gain the witness’s trust and obtain valuable information that helped solve the case.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer highlights the candidate’s ability to handle pressure and difficult individuals. It demonstrates their skills in remaining calm, prioritizing tasks, and building rapport. The example provides a specific situation where the candidate successfully navigated a challenging interaction.

3. Describe a situation where you had to gather and analyze evidence.
Example Answer:
“While investigating a hit-and-run accident, I was tasked with gathering and analyzing evidence to identify the perpetrator. I began by examining the scene, documenting the damage to the vehicle and collecting any physical evidence. I then interviewed witnesses and obtained security footage from nearby businesses. I carefully analyzed the evidence, including vehicle debris, witness statements, and security footage, to identify the type of vehicle involved and any potential suspects. Through this meticulous process, I was able to identify the responsible driver and bring them to justice.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer showcases the candidate’s ability to gather and analyze evidence. It describes the situation, the task of identifying the perpetrator, the actions taken to gather and analyze evidence, and the positive result of identifying the driver.

4. How do you stay organized and prioritize your workload?
Example Answer:
“As a Criminal Investigator, managing multiple cases and deadlines is crucial. I use a combination of tools and techniques to stay organized and prioritize my workload. I maintain a detailed case file for each investigation, ensuring all evidence, witness statements, and investigative notes are well-documented. I also use a task management system to track deadlines and prioritize tasks based on urgency and importance. Regularly reviewing my workload and adjusting my priorities as needed helps me stay on top of my responsibilities and ensure all cases are handled effectively.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer demonstrates the candidate’s organizational skills and ability to prioritize tasks. It describes the tools and techniques they use to manage their workload, highlighting their attention to detail and commitment to efficiency.

5. Tell me about a time you had to make a difficult decision.
Example Answer:
“During an investigation, I had to make a difficult decision about whether to pursue a lead that involved potential risks to an undercover officer. I carefully weighed the potential benefits of the lead against the risks involved. I consulted with my supervisor and considered all possible outcomes. Ultimately, I decided to proceed with caution, implementing additional safety measures to minimize the risks to the officer. The decision proved successful, as the lead ultimately led to the arrest of the suspect.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer demonstrates the candidate’s ability to make difficult decisions. It describes the situation, the task of weighing risks and benefits, the actions taken to gather information and consult with others, and the positive result of making a well-informed decision.

6. How do you maintain your composure and professionalism in stressful situations?
Example Answer:
“Criminal investigations often involve stressful situations, such as dealing with grieving families or confronting suspects. I’ve learned to maintain my composure by focusing on the task at hand and remaining objective. I also practice deep breathing techniques and positive self-talk to manage stress and anxiety. By staying calm and professional, I can effectively gather information, make sound judgments, and maintain the integrity of the investigation.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer highlights the candidate’s ability to maintain composure and professionalism under pressure. It describes their coping mechanisms for stress and their commitment to staying focused and objective.

7. What are your strengths and weaknesses as a Criminal Investigator?
Example Answer:
“One of my strengths is my attention to detail. I meticulously document all evidence and information, ensuring accuracy and completeness. I also possess strong analytical skills, allowing me to effectively analyze evidence and identify patterns. However, I am constantly working on improving my communication skills, particularly in delivering complex information to non-law enforcement personnel. I’ve been attending workshops and seeking feedback to enhance my communication abilities and ensure effective collaboration with all parties involved.”

Why this is a strong answer:
This answer demonstrates self-awareness and a commitment to professional growth. It identifies strengths relevant to the role, such as attention to detail and analytical skills, and acknowledges a weakness, demonstrating a willingness to improve.

Like a phone call interview – with your own AI interview coach.

Enter job title and company

Practice effectively for your dream job.

Get asked job-specific questions

Your AI interview coach will speak and ask you questions.

Speak back and view private feedback

Your coach will listen to you speak and reply with follow-up questions and private feedback.

Interview Feedback

Improve from real feedback

Frustrated by never hearing feedback from your interviews? We get it. Interview Smile is your way to get real feedback on how you did and to help you answer questions better. Come into your next job interview empowered with superhuman interview readiness.

Go from nervous to confident

Practice with your AI coach as much as you want to calm your interview nerves. Hone your pitch and boost your confidence with Interview Smile.

Interview Practice