Take a free practice interview

  • Practice answering questions and get real feedback to improve
  • Get job-specific questions at the company you want
  • 95% say this improved their performance

How to Handle an Interview Question About Difficult Decisions with Ethical Implications

Navigating difficult decisions with ethical implications is a common interview question. It’s essential to have a well-prepared answer showcasing your problem-solving and ethical reasoning skills.

What is the hiring manager looking for?

Hiring managers want to know if candidates possess strong ethical decision-making skills. They aim to assess if your values align with the company’s and how you navigate challenges when principles are at stake.

How to structure your answer

Structure your answer using the STAR (Situation, Task, Action, Result) method:
– Situation: Describe the scenario where you faced an ethical dilemma; set the context and provide relevant details.
– Task: Clarify the specific task or decision you were responsible for.
– Action: Detail the steps you took to address the ethical issues and make the decision. Highlight any research or consultations you conducted.
– Result: Explain the outcome of the decision, focusing on the positive impact it had on stakeholders and the organization.

Tips to answer this interview question

– Be honest and authentic in your response. Avoid fabricating or embellishing your answer.
– Focus on ethical reasoning and thoughtful decision-making rather than just the outcome.
– If you didn’t make the best decision in hindsight, acknowledge it and explain what you learned from the experience.

Things to avoid:
– Don’t provide irrelevant or unrelated examples.
– Steer clear of sensitive or controversial topics that may alienate the interviewer.
– Don’t give overly simplistic or vague answers.

Example interview answers to this question

Sample Answers:

Answer 1:
“In my previous role, I encountered a situation where a client requested a modification to a product that could potentially compromise safety standards. After careful consideration and consultation with technical experts, I decided to decline the request. I explained the ethical implications to the client and suggested alternative solutions that adhered to safety regulations. The client eventually agreed, appreciating my commitment to quality and safety.”

This answer effectively demonstrates the candidate’s ability to prioritize ethical considerations over financial gain. They exhibited strong decision-making skills by seeking expert advice and communicating transparently with the client.

Answer 2:
“As a manager, I had to decide between promoting a highly skilled employee with a history of misconduct or hiring an external candidate with no such issues. After careful consideration, I chose to conduct a thorough investigation. Upon finding evidence of the employee’s remorse and commitment to improvement, I offered them the promotion while implementing a mentorship program to address their behavioral challenges. This resulted in a positive transformation, enhancing their performance and fostering a culture of accountability within the team.”

This answer showcases the candidate’s ethical decision-making process, which considered both the employee’s potential and the company’s reputation. They demonstrated fairness, empathy, and a commitment to rehabilitation and growth.

Like a phone call interview – with your own AI interview coach.

Enter job title and company

Practice effectively for your dream job.

Get asked job-specific questions

Your AI interview coach will speak and ask you questions.

Speak back and view private feedback

Your coach will listen to you speak and reply with follow-up questions and private feedback.

Interview Feedback

Improve from real feedback

Frustrated by never hearing feedback from your interviews? We get it. Interview Smile is your way to get real feedback on how you did and to help you answer questions better. Come into your next job interview empowered with superhuman interview readiness.

Go from nervous to confident

Practice with your AI coach as much as you want to calm your interview nerves. Hone your pitch and boost your confidence with Interview Smile.

Interview Practice